Articles

Water Heater Closet Smells Musty? What to Check Around the Tank

Published 2026-10-29 by the ClearNest team

When Your House Doesn't Feel Right

63 pages of pictures and short steps. $2.99.

You open the little closet where the water heater lives, or walk past that corner of the garage or basement, and it smells damp. Not like gas, not like rotten eggs, just stale and musty, like a towel that never dried. The rest of the house may smell fine. That one spot doesn't.

Water heaters hold a lot of water in a small, closed-in space, and they usually sit somewhere nobody looks for months at a time. A small drip can go on for a long while before anyone notices. This guide walks through where the smell usually comes from, what you can check without taking anything apart, and when to hand it off to a plumber.

First, rule out the smells that are not musty

Before you start looking for damp, make sure you're dealing with the right kind of smell.

Gas. If you have a gas water heater and you smell something like rotten eggs or sulfur near it, don't go looking for the source. Leave the house, don't flip switches, and call your gas utility from outside. That's their job, and they will come out.

Rotten egg smell in the hot water only. If the smell is in the water itself, mostly when you run the hot tap, that's a different problem. It often has to do with the water supply and the metal rod inside the tank (called the anode rod). It's worth asking a plumber about, but it isn't the damp, musty smell this guide covers.

Burning or hot metal. A strong burning smell, scorch marks, or melted plastic near the heater means turn it off at the breaker or set a gas unit to "pilot" or "off" per the label, and call a pro.

If what you're smelling is plain musty, keep reading.

Where the musty smell usually comes from

A slow leak at a fitting. The pipes on top of the tank, the cold water inlet and the hot water outlet, have connections that can weep a little over time. So can the shutoff valve above the tank. A drip every few minutes doesn't make a puddle you'd notice, but it can keep the floor, the wall, or the bottom of a cabinet damp all the time.

The relief valve weeping. Every tank-style heater has a temperature and pressure relief valve, usually on the top or upper side, with a pipe running down toward the floor. Its job is to let water out if pressure or temperature gets too high. If it drips now and then, water can collect at the end of that pipe. A valve that drips often is worth having a plumber look at, since it can point to a pressure issue in the house plumbing, not just a worn valve.

A drain pan that holds water. Many heaters sit in a shallow metal or plastic pan. Some pans connect to a drain line; many don't. If a little water lands in the pan and has nowhere to go, it sits there in a warm, dark spot. Dust and lint settle in it, and it starts to smell.

The drain valve at the bottom. Near the base of the tank there's a small valve used to drain or flush it. These sometimes drip, especially after someone has used them. Look for rust or white mineral crust around it.

Condensation on the tank or pipes. On a humid day, or right after a lot of cold water comes into the tank, the outside of the tank and the cold pipe can sweat. In a tight closet with no air movement, that moisture can keep things damp. High-efficiency gas heaters can also make condensate that runs through a small drain tube, and if that tube is clogged or loose, the water ends up on the floor.

The tank itself. An older tank can start to leak from the bottom as the inside rusts through. Often the first sign is a damp spot or rust trail at the base that slowly gets bigger. This isn't something you can fix, but you want to know about it before it lets go.

A closed-in space with no airflow. Water heater closets are often small, with a solid door and maybe drywall on three sides. Even a tiny amount of moisture lingers in a space like that, and cardboard boxes, mops, or paint cans stored next to the heater soak it up.

A quick look you can do yourself

You don't need tools for this. Use a flashlight, and don't touch anything hot. The pipes and the valve on top can be very hot.

  1. Clear the space. Move anything stored in the closet or around the heater so you can see the floor and the base of the tank. Check the bottoms of those boxes and items for water marks.
  2. Look at the floor and the pan. Is there water, rust-colored stains, white crust, or a dark ring? Press a paper towel into the corners of the pan and around the base. A wet towel tells you water is getting there, even if you can't see it.
  3. Check the relief valve pipe. Follow the pipe from the valve down to its end. Is the end wet, stained, or crusty? Is there a little puddle under it?
  4. Look at the top of the tank. With the flashlight, check the pipe connections and the shutoff valve for green or white crust, rust, or drops of water. Crust usually means a slow drip that has been going on a while.
  5. Check the drain valve at the bottom. Look for drips or mineral buildup.
  6. Look at the wall and the floor around the closet. Swollen baseboard, soft flooring, peeling paint, or dark spots on the drywall near the floor can mean water has been reaching them for some time.
  7. Do the dry towel test. If you can't tell whether there's a leak, lay a dry paper towel or a piece of cardboard flat under the suspected spot and check it the next day. A sheet of paper under the relief valve pipe works too.
  8. Put a cheap hygrometer in the closet. A small digital humidity meter left in there for a few days shows whether that space stays much damper than the rest of the house.

Simple fixes for the small stuff

Dry out the pan and the floor. If you found a bit of water in the pan with no clear source, sponge it out, wipe the pan with a little dish soap and water, and let it dry. Then watch it for a week to see if water comes back.

Get stored things off the floor. Cardboard, rags, and mops hold moisture and smell. Move them out of the closet, or at least up on a shelf with some space around the heater. Leave the clearance the label on your heater asks for, especially for a gas unit that needs air to burn.

Let the space breathe a little. If the closet stays shut all the time, opening the door for a few hours a day can help it dry. Some water heater closets are built with louvered doors or vents on purpose, so don't block those. Don't add vents or change anything on a gas heater closet yourself, since gas units need a certain amount of air, and that's set by code. Ask a plumber or HVAC pro instead.

Clean what got wet. Wipe stained baseboards and the lower wall with a damp cloth and let them dry. If the drywall or flooring is soft, swollen, or has spreading dark spots, that's past a wipe and worth having someone look at.

Keep the condensate tube clear. On a high-efficiency unit, make sure the small drain tube is connected, not kinked, and running to where it should empty. If it's clogged, a plumber or the manufacturer's manual can tell you how it's meant to be cleared.

Things to leave to a plumber

  • Any active leak from the tank, a fitting, or a valve that you can't stop by gently snugging a loose hose connection by hand.
  • A relief valve that drips often, or one that you're thinking about testing. Testing it can cause an old valve to keep leaking.
  • Rust or a growing wet spot at the bottom of the tank.
  • Water damage in the wall, subfloor, or cabinet around the heater.
  • Anything to do with gas lines, venting, or the burner.
  • A tank that's well into its second decade. Many plumbers will suggest planning a replacement before it fails, so the water doesn't end up on your floor.

If the tank does start leaking and you need to stop the water, the cold water shutoff on the pipe above the heater is the one to close. Then turn off the power at the breaker for an electric heater, or set a gas heater's control to "off" or "pilot" as the label says, and call a plumber.

If the heater is dry and the smell is still there

Sometimes the water heater is innocent and just happens to share a closet with the real source. A few other places to check:

  • A floor drain nearby. If there's a drain in the same room, a dry trap can let up a sewer or musty smell: https://clearnestair.com/articles/sewer-smell-from-a-dry-trap
  • The furnace or air handler next to it. If the heater shares a closet with the furnace, the filter and return may be the cause: https://clearnestair.com/articles/the-return-vent-smells
  • A basement corner. If the heater sits in the basement, damp floors and walls are common culprits: https://clearnestair.com/articles/damp-basement-floor
  • A garage. Garages that smell musty have their own list of usual suspects: https://clearnestair.com/articles/garage-smells-musty
  • Under a sink or laundry hookup on the other side of the wall. A slow leak there can show up on your side first: https://clearnestair.com/articles/smell-under-the-kitchen-sink

Short note

This is a house check, not a diagnosis. If anyone at home has allergy or breathing symptoms that seem tied to one part of the house, talk to a doctor. Gas smells, active leaks, and water damage inside walls or floors go to the gas utility, a licensed plumber, or another qualified pro.

Check the rest of the house in pictures

When Your House Doesn't Feel Right is a picture book that walks through the everyday checks, from the basement to the bedroom closet, one photo at a time. It's $2.99 at https://clearnestair.com/book.

Related articles

Related guides

Browse all articles, all guides, or mold help by city.

Buy the picture book for $2.99 at clearnestair.com/book.

Not sure where to start? Take the free 60-second home air check.

All articles

Start with Ava